the photo

newyorkmug.jpg

the info

Dan Carlson
Houston, Texas

I'm a twentysomething white male with ambitions to be a professional film critic and generally spend my days getting paid to watch movies and write about it. A compulsive reader and stubborn cineaste, I take an often contrary stance to my more fundamentalist peers and upbringing by celebrating the pursuit of the good, and the Good, in life, love, art and film. If you watched enough episodes of certain TV shows — for starters, "The Hungry and the Hunted," "The Cut Man Cometh," "The Body," "The Zeppo," "Waiting in the Wings," "Out of Gas," "April Is the Cruelest Month," "20 Hours in America," "Colonial Day," "An Echolls Family Christmas," "Look Who's Stalking," "The Garage Door," "Charlie Gets Crippled," "Wind Sprints," and "Corner Boys" — you would understand me completely, and you'd also realize that much of my worldview and philosophical insights are heavily influenced by fictional works/programs, and many of the good things I've said in my life are just a regurgitation of someone else's imaginings, or at any rate a heartfelt attempt to interpret them. I guess I was made to be a film critic.

Calendar


February 2010
Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
1 2 3 4 5 6
7 8 9 10 11 12 13
14 15 16 17 18 19 20
21 22 23 24 25 26 27
28

The Counter

the world

« Review: No Country for Old Men |Main| My Musical Year In Review — 1 »

November 12, 2007

Clear Eyes, Full Hearts: Looking At The First Season Of "Friday Night Lights"

By Dan Carlson

fridaynightlights1109-1.png

• I have no idea what people who aren't from Texas think or feel when they watch "Friday Night Lights." Do they understand how real it all is? And I don't just mean the small town whose existence seems to revolve around high school football every fall, because people from towns all across the country think they know what that's about. I mean the run-down middle-class feel of it all. I mean the prayer in school. I mean the Dairy Queens and old cars and yards that have never quite recovered from garage sales in years past. The show is shot in Austin, and watching it felt like being home.

• But the series amps up the football melodrama to a certain degree; it's not just Texas, but the kind of heightened state of being Texans wish upon themselves. And that also works in the show's favor. In mixing real-life drama with (only slightly) exaggerated storylines, the show mirrors the state's actual football-based insanity with the voluntary pigskin fever people invite because they think it's their duty as Texans to have.

• Let's get the obvious out of the way: The extremely shaky handheld shooting style often detracts from the emotional power of some scenes. It's a rookie mistake to confuse shaky camera work with reality and immediacy, but the fault can be traced back to Peter Berg, whose directorial style (cf. Friday Night Lights, The Kingdom) places a premium on cinematography so jittery you'd think the d.p. had some kind of terrible palsy. There were so many times when I ached for a decent two shot instead of the extreme close-ups that drive the show; when Tami and Eric talk on the balcony of their hotel room after the State game, we see only fragments of their faces, sliding in and out of frame, and that's a moment I wanted to really see them, to get a sense of their bodies as they talked through Tami's news. (I'm going through all kinds of linguistic hell here to avoid too many spoilers; you're welcome.) Reducing the actors to close-ups too often does a disservice to those performers skilled enough to use their bodies to send the kind of messages dialogue will never adequately express. When two people are having a DTR, for instance, I want to be able to see (again, for instance) him move toward her and her flinch away, or her shoulders soften as she scoots just a little closer. And I feel like I missed some of those moments.

• Plus, there are almost no establishing shots. None. You get used to it after a while, in a kind of "Hey, I guess the action has shifted to the school again suddenly" kind of way.

• But those legitimate technical quibbles still can't dilute the series' awesome first season, which is about life and love and growing up, as cliched as that all sounds. And over the course of the first season, the show makes clear that the only way to grow up is to give up on your parents. It's no accident that, aside from the coach and his wife, every other set of parents is deeply flawed in some way, guilty of the neartsightedness or inflexibility that are the hallmarks of being a teen. This is an ingenious way to amplify the kids' struggles: They are faced with the choice of committing the sins of their fathers (or mothers) or choosing to move on. Tyra's mother is codependent and weak-willed; Lyla's father is unfaithful; Jason's parents attempt to control him; Tim's absentee father is an abusive drunk; etc., etc. For the young men and women of Dillon, Texas, growing up means letting go of your parents' failures and rescuing them from self-destruction, and then picking yourself up and moving on down the road.

• This is why the coach's decision to transfer to TMU has such resonance when it's unveiled before the State game. Throughout the entire season, the coach has acted as a loving parent to Julie and a willing mentor to his players, but the season finale and biggest game of the year is the chance for the team to finally realize that no adult, no grown-up, will ever stay with them all the way. In a rare moment of clarity, Smash says to his teammates, "It's up to us now." This is the boys' ultimate test: To go it alone.

• Additionally, the series has helped me understand just why exactly I don't care about college or pro sports at all, and the reason is so simple I'm amazed I haven't been able to articulate it until now. It's not that I categorically hate anything to do with sports; I like a good sports movie (Hoosiers, Bull Durham, Rudy) as much as the next guy. But "Friday Night Lights" works for me because it's not just about the game, but about the people playing it. I'm not just marveling at the grace of a fourth-quarter Hail Mary pass to win the game; I'm rooting for sophomore Matt Saracen to step it up and become a leader. I can't just watch a game for the athletic skill of it. I have to, on some level, be involved emotionally with the characters, which is why I get chills every time Jimmy Chitwood says, "I'll make it," but can't remember NFL standings week to week beyond what I overhear at the office. And the reason so many people do care about sports is that they believe themselves to be a part of that story; they've bought into the package being spoonfed to them on SportsCenter and are convinced that they know the players and are witnesses to a great human drama. This is all completely untrue, since no one really knows what's happening in these men's lives beyond what makes it to the police blotter, but it also helps you understand why hardcore fans speak of their teams victories in the first-person plural, e.g., "We totally came back there at the end for the win, and we deserved it."

• The point is that I don't care about sports; I care about the story, and whether it's a good one. And "Friday Night Lights" is a great one. It's warm, and challenging, and realistic, and knows that there is no reason to watch a game unless you've given your heart to the players on the field. It's stirring and inspiring in the truest sense in that it engages the viewer on a visceral, emotional level and also pushes them to do or be something better. It's in the way Coach Taylor looked at a bed-ridden, paralyzed Jason Street and says, "You're a good man. You're what makes guys like me want to coach." It's in the way Matt drops everything to help out his aging grandmother. And it's in the electric moment when Smash and the coach stare each other down in the pourding rain in the "Wind Sprints" episode. Coach has already broken the team's ego, but it's up to Smash to swallow his pride and begin to forge the scattered parts into a powerful whole. He grits his teeth and shouts, "Clear eyes, full hearts ... clear eyes, FULL HEARTS," as his teammates echo his cheer and they turn, suddenly energized, to attack the hill once more. It's impossible not to run with them.

fridaynightlights1109-2.png

Comments: 5

Rob

So when you say you love a good sports movie, and you leave out "The Replacements" and "The Program" - how is that supposed to make me feel? I'll tell you, sir - disenfranchised.

abijah

Why, yes. Yes, I did just cry while reading your overview. That's how much I love FNL. I love the whole aching sincerity of it. And it's not just Texas-it's my town too.

Lauren

Oh Dan... I just... love you.

Erik

Have to put in a word of support for anyone promoting FNL. However, I personally really like the jittery camera and lack of establishing shots.

The actors are incredible, but if the show framed shots in more conventional ways (which I feel is what you're asking for), it wouldn't be as good. It's not about seeing the moments you know are happening, it's about finding the details you would miss.

Prime example, and one of my favorite moments, is when Tami is standing on Coach's feet in the hotel room. It's a tiny detail, but that shot focused on that little bit says more than any wide angle would.

Anyway, amazing show, and great analysis.

SR

Great review. I think Season 1 was as close to perfect in TV that you can get. So perfect, in fact, that Season 2 is having a hard time measuring up, in my opinion. Dialogue in TV and movies really gets to me, and one of my pet peeves is when people say each other's names over and over again. I swear, in one scene with Riggins, Lyla and Jason, they said each other's names at least once in every damn sentence. Just lazy writing I think.

Ok, that off my chest, I hope this show gets picked up for a third season. It's really one of the only shows I look forward to every week.

Post a comment

the post

Questions? Comments? Complaints?

Drop 'em in the mailbag.

homefeed.png

The Lines

The Quotes

"The critic is the only independent source of information. The rest is advertising."
— Pauline Kael

"Film lovers are sick people."
— Francois Truffaut

"I hope I strike a blow for chubby bald men everywhere. I hope they rise like an army."
Paul Giamatti, quoted in the Los Angeles Times, 12/14/04

"Let others praise ancient times, I am glad I was born in these."
— Ovid

The Shelves

Dan's  book recommendations, reviews, favorite quotes, book clubs, book trivia, book lists

The Songs















Powered by
Movable Type 3.33

the wisdom

Remembering speechlessly we seek the great forgotten language, the lost lane-end into heaven, a stone, a leaf, an unfound door. Where? When?

O lost, and by the wind grieved, ghost, come back again.
— Look Homeward, Angel, Thomas Wolfe

Conservatives are not necessarily stupid, but most stupid people are conservatives.
— John Stuart Mill

We are all under the same mental calamity; we have all forgotten our names. We have all forgotten what we really are. All that we call common sense and rationality and practicality and positivism only means that for certain dead levels of our life we forget that we have forgotten. All that we call spirit and art and ecstasy only means that for one awful instant we remember that we forget.
— G.K. Chesterton

We were, for the briefest of moments, something greater than the sum of our uncertain parts; we were youth itself, in all its painful glory and sharp joy.
— Me, Fall 2003

There is a time in the lives of most writers when they are vulnerable, when the vivid dreams and ambitions of childhood seem to pale in the harsh sunlight of what we call the real world. In short, there's a time when things can go either way.
— Stephen King

Los Angeles, give me some of you! Los Angeles come to me the way I came to you, my feet over your streets, you pretty town I loved you so much, you sad flower in the sand, you pretty town.
Ask the Dust, John Fante